Excerpt from “Confessions of A Lesbian Dad”

Confessions of the Other Mother

By Polly Pagenhart

The Beginning
I didn’t always know I would be a lesbian dad. Sure, I always knew I was a lesbian - knew it somewhere deep inside, back when I was a tyke, back when I didn’t have a language for it all, before I knew the difference between lesbian and thespian, say, or Lebanese. My predilection for Ken dolls over Barbies, and my dogged determination to cross-dress as a swashbuckler every Halloween made it clear I wouldn’t be an ordinary girl, at the least. I also always knew I would be a parent: this was impressed upon me by my dad, despite the fact that my mom encouraged my sister and I to think that we could have a fulfilled life without becoming mothers. Both my parents were right, ultimately; I managed to become a parent without becoming a mother. It’s actually not as complicated as it sounds.

Parenthood is a Very Gendered Thing
So we all know there are mothers, and there are fathers. And there’s nothing in between, parentally speaking. Female parents are the mothers, male parents are the fathers. If there’s any modifying going on, it’s still given this fixed (and mutually exclusive) pairing: there can be step-moms and step-dads; adoptive moms and adoptive dads; old or young ones; rich or poor ones; world’s best or deadbeat ones. But the either/or, male/female fixity of the basic roles pretty much goes without saying. Unless, of course, one’s gender itself lies somewhere betwixt and between the poles, as mine does. This queers the do, as they say, highlighting how parenthood is implicitly a gendered binary.

If you’re trying to plot a middle path, you’ll find the underbrush a little thick in there. All of which became clear to me at a dinner party some years back, when my partner Jennifer and I were beginning to actively explore becoming parents.

We were at her brother Curtis’ house in Berkeley. At the table were his wife, their two young kids, my partner’s playwright/activist mother Martha - whom, in reference to Jennifer’s and my extra-legal partnership, I have taken to calling my mother “out-law” (as vs. in-law), much to her delight - and her partner Sandy, a Buddhist scholar and writer (and also a lesbian). We gather every Sunday night for dinner, and this week, guests at the table were Douglass, an old friend of Curtis’, and two old friends of my mother out-law’s, from her hippie days on a Cape Cod theater artist’s commune, some thirty years back.

We were slowly finishing the meal and the dinner plates were being cleared for dessert. The old Cape Cod commune-istas had caught up enough with my mother out-law and were now asking after notable events in the lives of her offspring. Soon, the focus of all attention was Jennifer’s and my campaign to have a baby. The usual bevvy of questions sprouted up.

Q: Which of us would bear the child?
A: My femme-bot sweetie, Jennifer; she’s always wanted to and I’ve always drawn a blank whenever I tried to imagine myself with child. With a child, great; with-child, eh, not so great.

Q: Would we want a known or an anonymous donor?
A: We were lighting candles and importuning all deities for a known donor, ideally a friend.

Q: Would we want to include him in the child’s life?
A: We hoped to, if he was amenable; that was a big appeal of the known donor thing. But it would be in a strictly avuncular fashion: we would be the only parents on the scene.

After we had outlined the whole shebang, someone generously offered that even if I wouldn’t be bearing the child, I would make a great mother. To which I found myself objecting; I had every reason to expect I’d be a splendid parent, but whatever I would be to my child, I wouldn’t be a mother.

A mix of amazement and amusement ensued. Eyebrows arched. Jaws went slack. I may as well have just rhapsodized about the nuanced political wisdom of George W. Bush.

“What do you mean you won’t be a mother? Of course you’ll be a mother!” This from one of the genial, erstwhile hippies. I surmised that her line of reasoning went; this nice young person doesn’t feel entitled to the title “mother,” and deserves some encouragement.

“No,” I insisted. “The name just doesn’t feel right to me. I’ll be a parent, definitely. I’ll be a loving, caring parent. But I just don’t feel motherly.”

The mood at the table slowly shifted from jovial to sober when it became clear that two equally passionately held beliefs were in complete opposition.
“But how can you not be a mother?” said my mother out-law’s sweetie. Who, by the way, wasn’t one herself. A mother, that is. Yet she seemed to be moving ahead of the pack to become the most flummoxed.

I felt the need to stand firm. “I can be something else. Something in
between a mother and a father.”

I was half making this up as I went along, half giving voice to something I was now realizing I’d felt for a long time. I thought of My Lesbian Husband, the book by Barrie Jean Borrich about her relationship with her butch lover. As a graduate student I had been friends with this lesbian husband, and looked up to her as a mentor of sorts, a tour guide in the ways of the butch intellectual. The debonair ladies’ gal-about-town.

“Maybe I’ll be a lesbian father. A dyke daddy, of sorts.”

The old hippie commune-istas were eyeballing my George Clooney haircut
and spiffy men’s duds with growing fascination and a glimmer of new insight. My brother out-law Curtis was smiling into his wine glass; for years he delighted me by calling me the brother he never had. He understood, and so, I sensed, did Douglass, both were self-examined, pro-feminist men with whom I had spent a goodly amount of time perusing and debating the perimeters of masculinity. Curtis was raised by a lesbian feminist, after all, and his friend Douglass had more lesbian friends than, well, most lesbians. If he didn’t have a beard and pee standing up most people would mistake him for one.

I found it challenging to be inventing and explaining at the same time, especially considering the table was collectively into its third or fourth bottle of wine by then. But, faced with a critical mass of sympathetic straight people, rapt with attention, plus two distinguished lesbian elders - neither of whom, it seemed, could intuitively make the leap from the leather-clad butch bar dykes they had known in their youth to the sweater-clad fatherly dyke I was proposing - I felt I had a responsibility to begin carving out a placefor myself, linguistically, socially, emotionally. After all, if I couldn’t make sense to a table full of liquored-up leftie hippie Buddhist artists, who could I make sense to? I cleared my throat, and tried to sketch out the back-story I thought would help this lesbian dad thing make sense to them. I told about how I was always betwixt and between, gender-wise. I told of my happy life gamboling about unfettered as a tomboy. How tomboy works great as a between-genders way station when you’re a preadolescent girl, but your goose is cooked when you hit puberty. Or mine was. I told how, when I came out at nineteen, I finally discovered a way to be in my skin that began to feel right, and how I took the next ten years arriving at a sense of, well, arrival, regarding my gender. How, poignantly, it was only after my mother died (and I felt I could no longer let her down) that I was finally able to make the last leg of my gender journey andembrace the gentle-manly butch within.

But impending parenthood, when it appeared to me as Motherhood or zip, just took me back to my adolescence in the mid-1970s, that time in my life when I felt hostage to a monolithic model of my proper gender role. The commune-istas were passing a bong back in ‘75, I’m sure, doing floor paintings with their long hair and swapping partners on low-slung mattresses behind beaded doorways and such. Meanwhile on the west coast my mother out-law’s partner was busy ditching her husband and jump-starting a feminist lesbian collective. But gender and sexual liberation hadn’t made it to teen life in my California suburb in the mid-70s, at least not beyond Helen Reddy’s single “I Am Woman (Hear Me Roar).” Instead, I was hemmed in by an implicit societal ultimatum to decommission the Hot Wheels, pluck my eyebrows, and act like a proper young woman. There was no Kasey Kasem Top 40 hit “I Am, Well, Not All That Womanly (Hear Me Try On Your Brother’s Clothes).”

So here I was now, looking at parenthood, feeling adrift, no parental prototype to steer by that didn’t trigger some cognitive tension at this visceral, gendered level. My own mother, while a far from traditional woman, still always wore a dress. (A friend in high school nicknamed her “Mrs. Butterworth,” after the maple syrup icon.) Generally speaking, images of motherhood overwhelmingly presuppose femininity. Not just femaleness, which I grant is reasonable, but femininity. Which for some of us gals is less- or even un-reasonable. So every time I conjured up images of parenthood (which I could only see through the lens of motherhood), I couldn’t help picturing traditional icons, June Cleavers and Laura Petries and Carol Bradys. Where were the butch moms, I wondered? Not so easy to find (or so I thought). Yet I was the very model of the mother who was masculine. Thwarted by the fact that in the collectivity of all my own experience and in popular culture, the only butch mother I could recall ever seeing was the character Marijo from a French film I had seen, French Twist, back in the mid-1990s.

That night at the dinner table I had, for the first time, begun to name (and defend) my parental self from a position slightly other than mother. Doing so helped me to realize how much my emotional access to parenthood was predicated on my feeling comfortable with the title mother and the femininity that presumably went along with it. Which I hadn’t really felt able to do, exactly. Proposing an alternative to mother that evening had led me to the threshold of my parenthood. Lo and behold, it was language that opened the door…

Continued in Confessions of the Other Mother, Beacon Press, 2006.





© 2003 Harlyn Aizley